12 December 2012

The Problem

There are an enormous number of people—and I am one of them—whose native religion, for better or worse, is Christianity. We were born to it; we began to learn about it before we became conscious; it is, whatever we think of it, an intimate belonging of our being; it informs our consciousness, our language, our dreams.     ~ Wendell Berry

Like most gay people, I grew up in a heterosexual family and in a heterosexually-oriented society. I learned the same lessons that most Americans in my generation (late baby boomers) learned about homosexuality -- that it’s a sin, or a sickness, something to be ashamed of, something to hide. I learned those lessons way before I had enough consciousness to reject them. This learning process, where GLBT people learn to hate themselves, is sometimes called “internalized homophobia.”

I also grew up attending a mainstream Protestant church. Again, I learned about God and Jesus well before I had enough capacity to question the things I was learning. Even though I rejected Christianity as a young adult, it’s the faith of my childhood. Just as when I lived in an adobe house in New Mexico I continued to dream about New England colonial buildings with attics and basements, my psyche is still full of the language and the mythical templates of Christianity. I am and will always be a cultural Christian, whatever I think about its validity as a religion.

PastorJeff_Background
Background, made from one block, five applications of color.

I have no idea if this print (or any of the prints I create in the next few months) will actually make it into the book I'm planning, but this print is where I have to start. It's an ugly print, based on an incredibly ugly video that went viral this past spring, where a young child who can’t be more than 5 years old is coached to sing a song with the refrain “Ain’t no homos gonna make it to heaven.” I hate this image, but it perfectly encapsulates the struggle with internalized homophobia that I’ve experienced in my life. And it also represents pretty perfectly the fact that the loudest voices against homosexuality in America for the past few decades have been the voices of the most passionate followers of Jesus.

Here’s the video, from a church in Indiana. Brace yourself...

10 comments:

Unknown said...

Oh, Annie, I had not seen that video, which is just SO dreadful and sad and maddening. The message is awful enough, but the fact that adults are encouraging this, applauding this, rewarding this, is just horrid. I consider this child's experience: I'm approved of, loved, given attention, for endorsing the "separateness" of this "other," their repugnance to "our people," and what we understand to be their damnation. Such a perversion and violation of children's trust in adults, and such a potent way to reproduce hatefulness.

I can understand beginning here. I look at this print and feel myself wanting so much for the wing to be the Holy Ghost trying to bring breath/light to these people, though it might just as easily be seen as some alternate-universe HG blessing this moment.

Arms around you.

Elizabeth Busey said...

Apologies from people of faith throughout the state of Indiana. I can only hope that as these children grow, they will experience that God's love is unconditional to all -- and their love of the world should be as well.

If you ever find yourself in Indiana on a Sunday, please consider coming to First United Church in Bloomington. You will find a place of safety, love and affirmation.

I am intrigued by your new series. Many churches (including mine) have an area devoted to art. You might consider sending your series on the road. I'm sure the churches could find a way to sponsor it.

Blessings and wishes for peace from Indiana.
Elizabeth

Annie B said...

Thank you, D. I like your Holy Spirit interpretation of the wing. I too see it as some kind of grace, some kind of hope.

And thank you, Elizabeth. Thank you for your apology, although it's only a twist of fate that this video happens to come from Indiana. It could easily have come from any state in our union. I will happily attend First United Church next time I'm in Bloomington. It sounds a lot like Edwards Church of Northamptom. Except that we don't have an art gallery -- great idea! Thank you for your blessings.

Sherrie York said...

My heart fills with respect, again, for your willingness to tackle such ugliness head-on, and to make something brave and beautiful from it. Thank you.

Katka said...

Years ago, and strictly out of innocent curiosity, we took in a revival meeting in Arizona. We wanted to see what the hype was all about but managed to stay about 15 minutes, only until the preacher thundered that "God will come down and kill all those faggots and lezzies" and everyone around us chanted "amen, amen" in borderline delirium.

It's so distressing to me how many people who call themselves followers of Jesus have missed the very essence of his teachings: love and tolerance.

Another difficult and weighty topic for you to tackle Annie. All the power to you...

Kate

Anita Thomhave Simonsen said...

Dear Annie..

I do admire your way of being true to yourself and wanting to express yourself as true as possible in your art....that is for me the way that you get energy and power in your work and I find it very interesting and will send you my best wishes for this project....
and I do share the other comments view on the fact that is horrible that some people uses the trust of a child to make it sing about a subject that says that God doesn´t give grace to people that are not right....this is not my way of thinking about christianity ( but something I have grown up hearing many times too)....The grace of God is there for everyone in my opinion...
and even for those people, who think they know to whom it will not be given...

good thoughts from me

Anita

Annie B said...

Thank you Sherrie, Kate, Anita. It's good to hear your thoughts and you give me courage to continue. Kate, you heard it in real life! Unfortunately, these attitudes aren't as rare as we who don't share them would like to believe.

Diane Cutter said...

Ah, Annie... I grew up in a Christian environment but never encountered this kind of thinking. Unfortunately, now through marriage, I have relatives that could have been in that audience. It pains both my husband and me that people could believe such tripe. I also appreciate the issues you are tackling so very valiantly. Keep forging ahead...


dinahmow said...

That obscene video comes close to child abuse, to my way of thinking.
You have and you display an admirable courage in this. I hope the support of "good" people helps. You certainly have mine.

Annie B said...

Thank you both.